Tithing in the Bible: Complete Scripture Guide (OT & NT)

Introduction: Why a Scripture-First Study Matters

This guide synthesizes seminary-level exegesis, Hebrew/Greek word studies, and a historical-grammatical approach to offer a clear, Scripture-anchored understanding of tithing in the Bible.

It draws on respected commentaries and theological dictionaries, engages the covenantal storyline from Genesis to Revelation, and situates key passages in their historical, economic, and liturgical contexts (patriarchal era, Mosaic administration, Second Temple Judaism, and the New Testament church).

Using careful exegesis and historical context, it distinguishes between Old-covenant tithe laws and New-covenant giving shaped by charis (grace), while highlighting enduring stewardship principles for today’s believers and church leaders.

The Hebrew Foundation: Tithing in the Old Testament

Maʿăśēr (מַעֲשֵׂר): Word Study & Cultural Frame

• Meaning: Maʿăśēr = “a tenth.” The term appears in Torah and later writings to denote the holy portion set apart to God from Israel’s produce and livestock.
• Context: Ancient Israel was an agrarian theocracy. Land, harvest, and herds were covenant gifts; the tithe ritually acknowledged Yahweh’s ownership and sustained temple worship and the priestly tribe.

Abraham and Melchizedek (Genesis 14:18–20)

Abram’s tenth to Melchizedek precedes the Mosaic Law. It functions as a voluntary, honorific gift given to a priest-king who blesses Abram in God’s name. Many see this as a pre-law precedent rather than a binding statute, yet it shows a pattern of honoring God’s priest with the first and best.

Jacob’s Vow (Genesis 28:20–22)

Jacob vows, conditionally, to give a tenth if God preserves and returns him in peace. This is a personal vow, not a codified law, revealing the tithe as an expression of covenant gratitude and dependence.

Levitical System & Temple Maintenance

• Leviticus 27:30–32: The tithe is “holy to the Lord,” set apart from the land’s yield and herds.
• Numbers 18:21–28: Because the Levites had no territorial inheritance, the tithe supported their ministry; Levites then tithed to the priests (a tithe of the tithe).
• Deuteronomy 12; 14; 26: Tithes intersect with festival joy, household worship, and care for the poor, embedding social justice within liturgical life.

Old Testament Tithing Passages

The Three Biblical Tithes: Understanding Mosaic Law

Many scholars describe the Mosaic tithe system as comprising three cyclical tithes (while others argue for overlapping uses of one basic tithe). The three-tithe reading helps explain Levitical support, festal participation, and social provision:

1. First Tithe (Levitical Support):
   • Texts: Numbers 18:21–24; Leviticus 27:30–33
   • Purpose: Sustains Levites who serve at the sanctuary and lack land inheritance.
   • Mechanics: A tenth of agricultural produce and herds given annually; Levites then offer a tithe of the tithe to the priests (Num 18:26–28).
2. Second Tithe (Festival/Rejoicing):
   • Texts: Deuteronomy 14:22–27
   • Purpose: Funds pilgrimage feasts at the chosen place (later Jerusalem), reinforcing joy, gratitude, and covenant community as worshipers consume part of their tithe before the Lord.
3. Third Tithe (Poor/Needy, Every Third Year):
   • Texts: Deuteronomy 14:28–29; 26:12–15
   • Purpose: Supports Levite, sojourner, fatherless, and widow in the local towns—structural justice embedded in Israel’s economy.

Comparison of the Three Tithes

"

✧

❋

✧

Scholarly Note: Some traditions read Deuteronomy as describing uses of a single tithe rather than three distinct tithes. Either way, Torah binds worship, priestly provision, and social care into Israel’s economic life.

✧

✦

✧

— Scripture Inspiration —

Jesus and Tithing: New Testament Perspective

Matthew 23:23 (with the parallel in Luke 11:42) critiques Pharisaic legal precision that neglects moral weight: justice, mercy, and faithfulness. The Lord says:

"

✧

❋

✧

ταῦτα δὲ ἔδει ποιῆσαι κἀκεῖνα μὴ ἀφιέναι
“These you ought to have done, without neglecting the others.”

✧

✦

✧

— Scripture Inspiration —

Here Jesus affirms the ethical priorities of the Law while addressing Old-covenant observers prior to the cross. He neither abolishes the heart behind tithing (honoring God’s ownership) nor reduces righteousness to mere percentage compliance. His teaching presses integrated piety—meticulous devotion joined to mercy and justice—anticipating the New-covenant transformation where generosity flows from the gospel.

Ceremonial Law & Transition: Jesus fulfills Torah (Matt 5:17). As the temple era closes (A.D. 70), priestly and cultic structures give way to a Spirit-formed community whose giving is shaped by grace, love, and mission, not by a centralized temple tax.

Apostolic Teaching: Grace-Based Giving in the Early Church

2 Corinthians 8–9: Theology of Charis (χάρις)

Paul frames Christian giving as grace-enabled participation in God’s generosity: “see that you excel in this act of grace.” Giving is:

• Willing and eager (8:3–4)
• Proportional to means (8:12–14)
• Cheerful rather than coerced (9:7)
• God-ward and doxological (9:12–15)

1 Corinthians 16:1–2: System and Regularity

Believers set aside on the first day of every week in keeping with prosperity (“as he may prosper”), establishing a pattern of systematic, proportionate offerings for ministry needs.

Acts 2:44–47; 4:32–37: Radical Sharing

The Jerusalem church models voluntary, Spirit-prompted generosity, selling property to meet needs—kingdom economics fueled by unity, worship, and mission.

Word Study: ἀπαρχή (aparchē, “firstfruits”)

“Firstfruits” language signals that early Christian giving—though not bound to Israel’s cult—retains the principle of God-first honor and missionward consecration.

Old-Covenant Law vs New-Covenant Grace

Malachi 3:10: The Most-Quoted Tithing Verse Explained

Historical setting: Post-exilic Judah struggles with priestly negligence and waning devotion. “Storehouse” refers to temple chambers that held grain and provisions for cultic service and those who served. God indicts withholding as covenant unfaithfulness and issues a unique invitation: “Test me in this”, promising sufficiency and protection from devourers.

Covenantal nuance: Malachi addresses a people under the Mosaic covenant. Christians today read the promise through Christ, recognizing that while the temple economy is fulfilled, the God-honoring pattern of first and best remains instructive. Guard against transactional prosperity readings; the text calls for covenant fidelity, not quid-pro-quo giving.

Biblical Principles for Modern Christian Giving

1. Systematic (1 Cor 16:2): Plan your giving with intentionality and order.
2. Cheerful (2 Cor 9:7): God values motive as much as amount.
3. Proportional (2 Cor 8:12): Give in line with means; grow as God prospers you.
4. Sacrificial (Mark 12:41–44): The widow’s mite reveals kingdom calculus.
5. Holistic Stewardship: All we have is God’s; giving is one practice within a life of worship, justice, and mercy.

Practical Application

• Start with a Plan: Many believers adopt 10% as a training-wheels discipline, then grow beyond it as grace enlarges capacity.
• Prioritize the Local Church: New Testament patterns focus on gospel ministry and the poor (Gal 2:10; 1 Tim 5).
• Budget Wisely: Avoid giving that creates harmful debt or neglects family obligations (1 Tim 5:8).
• Use Tools: For proportional planning, see the Net vs Gross Tithe Calculator and the practical explainer How Much Are You Supposed to Tithe?

Hebrew/Greek Word Studies (Expanded)

• מַעֲשֵׂר (maʿăśēr) — “tenth, tithe”:
  Denotes the holy tenth separated to Yahweh; in Levitical law it becomes a covenant institution for worship, priestly support, and mercy.
• ἀπαρχή (aparchē) — “firstfruits”:
  First portion dedicated to God, signaling consecration of the whole. In the NT it also functions metaphorically (e.g., believers as firstfruits), reinforcing God-first priorities.
• χάρις (charis) — “grace, favor”:
  The engine of Christian giving in 2 Corinthians 8–9; grace creates generosity and crowns it with thanksgiving to God.

Historical Context That Shapes Interpretation

• Second Temple Economics: Pilgrimage tithes and offerings sustained worship in Jerusalem; agricultural cycles and sabbatical laws structured communal life.
• Roman Taxation (NT era): Imperial taxes burdened Judea, sharpening debates about what belonged to Caesar vs. God (cf. Matt 22:21).
• Early Church Finances: Collections for the Jerusalem poor (Rom 15; 1 Cor 16; 2 Cor 8–9) reveal a inter-church economy of solidarity and mission.
• Patristic Witness: Early fathers emphasized almsgiving, church support, and care for the poor as hallmarks of Christian piety (e.g., Chrysostom on generosity; Augustine on ordered love).

Denominational Perspectives (Brief, Balanced)

• Reformed/Presbyterian: Many see the moral principle of proportionate giving as abiding, with 10% a wise norm and starting point rather than binding statute.
• Catholic: Emphasizes precept of supporting the Church’s needs; encourages regular, proportionate giving as part of discipleship and social teaching.
• Baptist/Evangelical: Strong on faithful, cheerful, and mission-minded generosity; many churches commend the tithe as a baseline without legal compulsion.
• Pentecostal/Charismatic: Often champion faith-filled generosity and kingdom investment, alongside care for the poor and global mission.

Responsible Stewardship: Pastoral Balance

• Financial Wisdom: Give generously within wise budgeting; avoid manipulative appeals.
• Grace over Legalism: New-covenant giving flows from love, gratitude, and the Spirit’s leading.
• Progressive Growth: Train the heart through regular, incremental increases as means allow.
• Community Accountability: Elders and finance teams should model transparency, integrity, and mission alignment.
• Cultural Sensitivity: Encourage equitable sacrifice, not uniform amounts—contexts vary widely.

References & Further Study

Primary Biblical Texts
Genesis 14:18–20; 28:20–22 · Leviticus 27:30–33 · Numbers 18:21–28 · Deuteronomy 12; 14:22–29; 26:12–15 · 1 Samuel 8 (royal economics) · 2 Chronicles 31 · Nehemiah 10; 12–13 · Malachi 1–3 · Matthew 5; 22:15–22; 23:23 · Luke 11:42 · Acts 2; 4 · Romans 15:25–28 · 1 Corinthians 9; 16:1–2 · 2 Corinthians 8–9 · Galatians 2:10 · 1 Timothy 5.

Classic Commentaries & Theological Works

• Matthew Henry, Commentary on the Whole Bible (notes on Leviticus 27; Numbers 18; Malachi 3; Matthew 23; 2 Corinthians 8–9).
• John Calvin, Commentaries (esp. on Malachi; Gospel harmonies) and Institutes (on Christian liberty and almsgiving).
• John Chrysostom, Homilies (various, on almsgiving and stewardship).
• Augustine, Sermons and City of God (ordered love, the poor, and church support).
• Lexica/Dictionaries: TDNT (Kittel) entries on χάρις, ἀπαρχή; NIDOTTE entries on מַעֲשֵׂר; BDAG (for NT Greek usage).

Academic & Historical Studies

• Craig L. Blomberg, Neither Poverty nor Riches: A Biblical Theology of Possessions.
• David W. Baker & Gordon J. Wenham (eds.), Dictionary of the Old Testament: Pentateuch (entries on tithes, firstfruits, Levites).
• E. P. Sanders, Judaism: Practice and Belief (Second Temple practices).
• Ben Witherington III, Jesus and Money (economic backdrop of the Gospels).

Final Pastoral Encouragement

Across Scripture, God’s ownership, worshipful gratitude, care for the vulnerable, and gospel mission converge. The Old-covenant tithe taught Israel to live before God with first and best. In Christ, the Spirit forms a people who give regularly, proportionately, cheerfully, and sacrificially—not under compulsion, but compelled by grace.

If you’re planning your giving rhythm, try these next steps on-site:

• Start with a concrete plan using the Net vs Gross Tithe Calculator.
• Read How Much Are You Supposed to Tithe? for practical frameworks.
• Explore whether and when it’s appropriate to direct gifts to mercy needs in Can I Give My Tithe to the Poor Instead of Church?